Two situations when rupee cost averaging doesn't work in the market! Read the complete article before closing your mutual funds!

When prices are low, your fixed SIP investment buys more units or shares, and when prices are high, it buys fewer. This gradual accumulation results in a lower average cost per unit over time, mitigating the impact of market volatility.

Rupee cost averaging is a strategy commonly used by people who trade or invest in mutual funds for the long term. It involves putting a set amount of money into investments at regular intervals, no matter what's happening in the market. This method helps lessen the impact of market ups and downs by buying more units when prices are low and fewer when they're high. The goal is to reduce the average cost per unit over time and encourage steady investing habits.

When prices are low, your fixed SIP investment can get you more units or shares, and when prices are high, you'll get fewer. This steady accumulation helps bring down the average cost per unit over time, which helps reduce the effect of market ups and downs. Regardless of whether an investor chooses to save through SIPs in Small-Cap, Mid-Cap, or Large-Cap mutual funds, one common factor remains is rupee cost averaging.

It promotes concentrating on long-term growth instead of trying to time the market. However, does this strategy succeed in all market situations, such as when the market is going up, moving sideways, or going down? In this article, we'll delve into two market phases where rupee cost averaging may not benefit you.

Also read 10 crucial factors to consider when evaluating a company's order book!

From Bullish to Bearish Phase

Let’s examine the market movements from 2006 to 2008, before the crash. During this period, the Nifty index surged from approximately 2800 to a peak of around 6360 in 2008, before plummeting back to its initial levels by October 2008. If you sold your investments upon seeing the market fall, the following would be the result of your investment values of Rs 1000 SIP investments made every month during this period. In this phase, you experienced a bullish phase earlier and then eventually a significant downturn.

With a loss of over 31% in absolute terms or around 24% fall in your investment in terms of annualized returns, did rupee cost averaging work here? No right.  It will work surely when it halts for some time at the lower levels and starts moving toward the upside; then the investment returns will be impressive.

From Upside Trend to Sideways and Finally Breakdown Towards Downside

As an investor or traders, we dislike consolidation unless it aligns with our expected directions. During consolidation, stocks or mutual funds typically remain at the same price or within a narrow range. While your fixed SIP amount accumulates units during consolidation if the breakout goes against your direction, it won't help your investment grow; rather, it may reduce your investment value. Suppose an investor began investing on the date mentioned in the image and experienced a good rally, followed by consolidation. However, instead of continuing the trend, it eventually falls and breaks the consolidation towards the downside. Here's how your investment value would evolve during this period.

Investors will profit when the market moves upwards, consolidates for a period, and eventually breaks out of consolidation towards the upside, continuing its original trend.

How SIP works:

In conclusion, while rupee cost averaging is widely popular, its effectiveness can vary across different market phases. The above analysis demonstrates that during a transition from a bullish to a bearish phase, rupee cost averaging may not always yield favourable results. Similarly, in scenarios where a market trend shifts from an upside trend to consolidation and ultimately breaks down toward the downside, the strategy may not prove beneficial. Stocks have the potential to provide multibagger returns; on the other hand, mutual funds are often considered more stable investments. Each one has its own features, and investors must taste both types of securities. Additionally, rupee cost averaging is also present when investors do stock SIP.  Hence, investors must be mindful of market dynamics and adapt their investment strategies, accordingly, considering both the potential benefits and limitations of rupee cost averaging.Stocks can give investors a multibagger returns while mutual funds are known for stability and